7 photos on this listing. See all on Google Maps.
About New Choice Nails
New Choice Nails is a nail salon in Cortlandt Manor, New York. It holds a 4.5 rating from 101 Google reviews, and reviewers most often mention the friendly staff and the quality of the nail work. Most of the reviews are five stars, with one critical review about wait times and prices.
What New Choice Nails offers
The salon offers on-site nail services, and reviews name builder gel extensions and pedicures. One reviewer who works with her hands says the builder gel nails stay on through constant wear and do not lift even when grown out.
Reviews describe a salon that serves families. One reviewer came for the first time with her mother, and another brought her daughters.
- Builder gel extensions
- Pedicures
- Nail color selection
- On-site nail services
What customers say about New Choice Nails
Most reviewers are highly satisfied. Several name the staff, including Kelly, Lori and Rita, and describe the salon as clean, peaceful and welcoming. Reviewers call the work exceptional and say the nails come out perfect.
Value is mixed. One five-star reviewer says the prices are reasonable, while another says the cost was a little high but worth it. One review from a month ago is a one-star complaint: a 1 PM reservation was not seated until 1:30 PM, the color selection was poor, the pedicure quality fell short, extra fees were added at the end, and a basic pedicure took an hour and a half.
New Choice Nails hours, prices and payment
New Choice Nails is open Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday, from 9:30 AM to 7 PM. It is closed on Sundays.
The business accepts credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments. Reviewers describe prices from reasonable to expensive, depending on the service.
Location and accessibility at New Choice Nails
New Choice Nails is at 3535 Crompond Rd in Cortlandt Manor, New York. Its Google profile lists on-site parking, and the car park is wheelchair accessible.
The entrance and the toilet are both wheelchair accessible, and the salon has an accessible restroom.
Questions about New Choice Nails
Is New Choice Nails open on Sunday?
No. New Choice Nails is closed on Sundays. It is open Monday, Tuesday, and Thursday through Saturday, from 9:30 AM to 7 PM.
Does New Choice Nails take credit cards?
Yes. New Choice Nails accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments such as contactless phone payments.
Is New Choice Nails wheelchair accessible?
Yes. The car park, the entrance, and the toilet are all wheelchair accessible, and the salon has an accessible restroom.
How is New Choice Nails rated?
New Choice Nails has a 4.5 rating from 101 Google reviews. Five of the six review excerpts give five stars, and one gives one star.
Written by the SpaSpot editorial team from this business's public Google listing and 101 customer reviews, then checked against the listing data on November 10, 2026. It describes what customers report and is not medical advice. How we research and write listings · Report a correction.
- Diane Cohena month ago
I wouldn’t go anywhere else! Kelly, Lori and all of the staff are wonderful. The salon is peaceful and clean. Prices are reasonable and the work is exceptional!
- Addison Kinga month ago
We had a reservation for 1pm and didn’t get seated until 1:30pm, the color selection was poor, overall pedicure was not of good quality, added fees at the end and took and way overpriced, and hour and a half for a basic pedicure
- Brianna T10 months ago
I’ve been coming to this salon for months now after years of searching for my perfect nail tech. I finally found her! Rita is absolutely incredible. I do builder gel extensions and she always does a phenomenal job. I work with my hands all the time and even through constant wear, they stay on! Even if I let them grow out a bit too long, they never lift or pop off. She takes her time to do solid application, shape them just how I want (no other nail tech I’ve gone to has been willing to do short stilettos or coffin), and makes sure there’s no snags or funky edges. She also paints them beautifully, smooth and evenly, with no streaks or missed spots. The shoulder massages here are also absolutely amazing. I have terrible posture so my neck and upper back is always sore, but I always feel so refreshed afterwards. 10/10 all around, I have never left feeling anything but thrilled!
- Team Iwin11 months ago
Prompt clean and friendly...New spot for my Daughters and I... 😀
- angelagh regan11 months ago
New Choice is truly the best — I’ve been coming here for years and wouldn’t go anywhere else. I’ve been getting my nails done here since I was a kid with my mom, and now at 25 I still won’t trust any other salon. The quality has always been amazing, and no matter who you get, your nails come out perfect every single time. The owner, Kelly, is incredible. She’s so friendly, welcoming, and genuinely cares about her customers. She even remembers everyone — it makes the whole experience feel personal. She normally does my eyebrows and she’s the only person I trust with them. The salon is clean, consistent, and so comfortable. If you’re looking for a place that makes you feel taken care of while giving you the best nails and brows, New Choice is the one. Highly, highly recommend! 💖💅✨
- Jennifer Braun11 months ago
Went here with my mom for the first time today and it was an awesome experience. All the staff was extremely nice and attentive and our nails came out great. A little expensive which i didn’t mind because it was worth it, will be going back.
- Joanna Ca year ago
I followed Ashley here from her former salon, and even though it's further away than I'd normally go, she is so good that it's well worth the trip! I've gotten pedis and gel manis from Ashley, and her work is meticulous. She takes a real interest in the health of your nails and works with you to achieve your goals regarding nail strength and length. One of my favorite things about New Choice is the incredibly vast selection of gel colors, with hundreds and hundreds to choose from.
- Saraha year ago
*June 5, 2025 I do not know why but, for some reason when I had came to this nail salon this past Wednesday, June 4th, with one of my friends, considering the 4 of us, (1 being the bride and the other 3, including myself being bridesmaids) went to this particular salon for us all to get manicures and pedicures, (in the French style); I just don't know but, something didn't sit right with me after I had to pay for my manicure and pedicure...Like, almost as if I had been cheated in having to pay more than what was required of the service alone. I had made sure in discussing this situation with my mother where both her and I had made the decision in visiting this nail salon again to confirm for why the owner of this premise was coming up with $82 as the overall price for me to pay but, then when provided the receipt shows $47...I personally had the intention to pay only the price for the service and add a $5 tip; it really still confuses me why the overall end price came up to $82, rather than being less than that...I would assume it is because I had requested to the nail stylist to receive a regular French manicure and pedicure but, instead she had given me the gel kind, (which I believe is why it came out to that amount). If I had to provide an honest rating for this review, I would give this nail salon 3 stars instead of 2...The reason I am providing the 3 stars, is because both paint jobs of my toe nails and finger nails were of good quality from the nail stylist but, not from having to pay such an expensive amount near the end from the owner. I will never be coming back to this salon, considering the owner had confused me at the time, I will just take my business to Alice Nails, that is a nail salon near me where I usually go to get a manicure and other services done.
- Eugene of Savoya year ago
Didn't feel welcome, bad service, neglectful, don't bother
- Yuliana Jimeneza year ago
Rating only, no written review.
- Jean Rakotz2 years ago
Rating only, no written review.
- Karen Fusco2 years ago
I have only done pedicures here so far but they last and I'm never disappointed. Also very friendly vibe and lots of workers
- Maddy McArn2 years ago
I love getting nail art done here. The owner is always checking in to make sure I’m happy throughout the process, and is always so accommodating when I’m scheduling last minute. I come here exclusively!
- Rhea2 years ago
Ladies! First time getting my nails done here and they did not disappoint. Friendly and professional staff, clean environment, and Ann did a great job. Thank you 🙏 …
- Jennifer Piciocchi2 years ago
New choice nails is a great nail salon. Everyone is so caring and patient. I highly recommend them!
- Sharon Fenster2 years ago
New Choice continues to be one of the best nail salons in the area. I especially like that they are scrupulous about cleanliness as I have had negative experiences with other local salons who are not as careful. Ann is an amazing operator and Kelly the owner is also amazing. They are competent at nail designs and decorations but not superior. Basic nail designs is their forte. Definitely worth checking out!
- Emilie Goodrich2 years ago
My favorite ladies in the world! Been coming here for 10 years and moved away but will schlep up just to get a good mani. Always good conversation and they have fun trying new things I bring from Pinterest. ;) My gel manis will last almost a month!
- Sarah T - Hudson Valley Guide3 years ago
Very clean. Great spa pedicure. Always leave happy with my nails. Nice staff.
- karen mcgannon3 years ago
Kelly is a wonderful boss and business owner. The place is peaceful and the energy is amazing. She has a meticulously clean place and healthy atmosphere. My pedicure was awesome and had a last minute manicure too Will definitely go again and share my experience with others!!
- Nathan Hilterbrand3 years ago
Top notch service, very friendly bilingual staff
- Taina Munoz3 years ago
Love this place! Same quality no matter who the nail technician is!
- Natalia Padilla3 years ago
Very nice and clean place, the ladies who did my nails were extremely sweet and gentle the prices are just a bit high.
- Christina3 years ago
Fastest gel pedicure I've ever gotten. Odd that they soak and scrub your feet after the polish application though. Toes still look great.
- Bobby Clarke3 years ago
My wife's number 1 choice, With so many in the area, this is the only place where she gets what she wants,, she usually only lets Rita work on her nails , this girl is amazing with her work and the designs she paints on finger's
- Donna Ruperto3 years ago
Rating only, no written review.
Showing the 25 reviews Google marks as most relevant, of 101. Read all on Google.
Location
3535 Crompond Rd, Cortlandt Manor, NY 10567, United StatesGet directions
Nail salon in Cortlandt Manor, NY
New Choice Nails serves Cortlandt Manor. Its 4.5 rating comes from 101 customer reviews on Google. Compare it with every spa and salon in Cortlandt Manor, or browse nail salons across New York.











