Sag Harbor Nail

2 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United States

All hours

Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 1 of 10Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 2 of 10Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 3 of 10Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 4 of 10Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 5 of 10Sag Harbor Nail, nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY, photo 6 of 10

10 photos on this listing. See all on Google Maps.

About Sag Harbor Nail

Sag Harbor Nail is a nail salon in Sag Harbor, New York, at 2 Bay St. It holds a 4.0 rating from 45 Google reviews, and reviewers most often name individual technicians and the nail work they do. Opinions are split, with some visitors reporting rough filing and unmet expectations.

What Sag Harbor Nail offers as a nail salon in Sag Harbor

Clients come for the nail work itself, and reviewers name particular technicians as the reason they return. One five-star reviewer who is particular about nails says the technician understood a long, thin, natural-looking pale pink look right away.

  • Manicures
  • Pedicures
  • Waxing
  • Nail filing

What customers say about Sag Harbor Nail

Of the six review excerpts shown, two are five-star reviews that praise named technicians and describe the salon as busy for good reason. The other four rate it one or two stars and describe different problems.

One review from a month ago describes a technician who filed so aggressively that the nails reached raw flesh, and says the reviewer repeatedly asked her to stop. Another technician finished the pedicure. A review from three months ago says the reviewer booked by phone and was told only cash was accepted, a policy that was not mentioned when booking.

A two-star review from three months ago says the customer service was good but the nail work was poor. Another one-star review from the same period describes filthy, broken pedicure chairs.

Hours, prices and payment at Sag Harbor Nail

The salon is open every day of the week, from 10:00 AM to 7:30 PM. The Google profile lists credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments as accepted.

Accessibility and parking at Sag Harbor Nail

The Google profile lists a wheelchair-accessible car park and a wheelchair-accessible toilet, along with a restroom for customers.

Before you visit Sag Harbor Nail

The Google profile states that an appointment is required. One reviewer who booked a pedicure for three people was offered availability for only one, and was told the group could not sit together, even though the group had asked to be seated together.

A reviewer with two daughters mentions the visit as a family appointment, which shows the salon sees parents booking with children.

Questions about Sag Harbor Nail

Is Sag Harbor Nail open on Sunday?

Yes. Sag Harbor Nail is open every day of the week, including Sunday, from 10:00 AM to 7:30 PM.

Does Sag Harbor Nail take cards?

Its Google profile lists credit cards, debit cards and NFC mobile payments as accepted. One reviewer from three months ago reported being told the salon accepted only cash.

Is Sag Harbor Nail wheelchair accessible?

The Google profile lists a wheelchair-accessible car park and a wheelchair-accessible toilet at Sag Harbor Nail.

How is Sag Harbor Nail rated?

Sag Harbor Nail has a 4.0 rating from 45 Google reviews. Several reviewers praise named technicians, while some report rough filing and poor results.

Written by the SpaSpot editorial team from this business's public Google listing and 45 customer reviews, then checked against the listing data on November 10, 2026. It describes what customers report and is not medical advice. How we research and write listings · Report a correction.

Reviews

45See all
4.0

Good

Based on 45 Google reviews from clients

  • Nikaa month ago

    It’s my first ever bad review I’m by life . On August 18 I was scheduled to what was likely an inexperienced technician I don’t know but she filed my nails down so aggressively that she reached the raw flesh. I repeatedly asked her to stop filing, but she kept going, and I ended up with completely ruined nails. Another technician stepped in to finish the pedicure, but the pain was simply unbearable. It is September 11th now, and my nails hurt terribly whenever I wear shoes, going to this salon was a huge mistake:( Incidentally, on the day of the appointment, other technicians saw that my nails had been ruined, yet they still charged me the full price without offering a discount and the lady even asked if I wanted to leave a tip:)

  • Michele brown3 months ago

    I had a very disappointing experience at Sag Harbor Nails. I called ahead and made an appointment. When I arrived, I found out they only accept cash. The person who took my appointment never mentioned this. I only found out because I overheard him discussing the cash-only policy with another customer and asked about it. When I explained that no one had told me, the technician insisted that he tells everyone. I explained that I work at a bank and would have withdrawn cash beforehand if I had known, but she continued insisting that I had been told. Rather than go back and forth, I stayed quiet because I just wanted to get my nails done. Unfortunately, the service only got worse. I asked for short nails, but she clipped only one hand before starting the acrylic application. When I pointed out that the other hand hadn’t been clipped, she said she would file them down later. Some of my natural nails were left partially clipped and hanging, and when I asked about it, she again said she would fix them after applying the acrylic. Throughout the appointment, she was twisting and pulling my fingers in uncomfortable positions. I needed my nails done, so I stuck it out, hoping the final result would make up for it. When she told me I was finished, my hands were still covered in nail dust, the nails were uneven, and they hadn’t been properly shaped or finished. I told her she couldn’t possibly be done because there was still nail dust all over my hands. Instead of cleaning them, she told me to go wash my hands and then asked if I wanted cuticle oil. Not even a little lotion was offered after the service. When she asked if I liked my nails, I honestly said no. She had also asked if I wanted shimmer before starting, and I clearly said no because I just wanted a simple set of nails. She put shimmer on anyway. Ironically, the shimmer made them look a little better than they did before. The quality of the acrylic application was also poor. The sides of several nails were rough and unfinished, and within a day the acrylic had already started lifting and coming off around the edges. I actually had to file the sides down myself when I got home because they were so ragged. To top it off, when it was time to pay, she asked if I wanted to leave a tip. Even after this experience, I still said yes out of respect and told her $15. She heard me but then asked if I meant $50. I had to repeat, “No, fifteen—one-five.” This was, without a doubt, the worst nail salon experience I’ve ever had. Between the poor communication, rushed and unfinished work, uncomfortable service, and dismissive attitude, it was a frustrating experience from start to finish. I won’t be returning, and I cannot recommend this salon based on my experience. I also paid $217 plus change not including tip.

  • Michele Brown3 months ago

    Good customer service even though they didn’t understand a word I was saying. They did a horrible job with my nails. I made the above comment two year’s ago. Today is 08/03/2026. I wanted to try again and this was my experience. Never again! These pictures were taken two days after. This is after I filed it down a bit. I had a very disappointing experience at Sag Harbor Nails. I called ahead and made an appointment. When I arrived, I found out they only accept cash. The person who took my appointment never mentioned this. I only found out because I overheard him discussing the cash-only policy with another customer and asked about it. When I explained that no one had told me, the technician insisted that he tells everyone. I explained that I work at a bank and would have withdrawn cash beforehand if I had known, but she continued insisting that I had been told. Rather than go back and forth, I stayed quiet because I just wanted to get my nails done. Unfortunately, the service only got worse. I asked for short nails, but she clipped only one hand before starting the acrylic application. When I pointed out that the other hand hadn’t been clipped, she said she would file them down later. Some of my natural nails were left partially clipped and hanging, and when I asked about it, she again said she would fix them after applying the acrylic. Throughout the appointment, she was twisting and pulling my fingers in uncomfortable positions. I needed my nails done, so I stuck it out, hoping the final result would make up for it. When she told me I was finished, my hands were still covered in nail dust, the nails were uneven, and they hadn’t been properly shaped or finished. I told her she couldn’t possibly be done because there was still nail dust all over my hands. Instead of cleaning them, she told me to go wash my hands and then asked if I wanted cuticle oil. Not even a little lotion was offered after the service. When she asked if I liked my nails, I honestly said no. She had also asked if I wanted shimmer before starting, and I clearly said no because I just wanted a simple set of nails. She put shimmer on anyway. Ironically, the shimmer made them look a little better than they did before. The quality of the acrylic application was also poor. The sides of several nails were rough and unfinished, and within a day the acrylic had already started lifting and coming off around the edges. I actually had to file the sides down myself when I got home because they were so ragged. To top it off, when it was time to pay, she asked if I wanted to leave a tip. Even after this experience, I still said yes out of respect and told her $15. She heard me but then asked if I meant $50. I had to repeat, “No, fifteen—one-five.” This was, without a doubt, the worst nail salon experience I’ve ever had. Between the poor communication, rushed and unfinished work, uncomfortable service, and dismissive attitude, it was a frustrating experience from start to finish. I won’t be returning, and I cannot recommend this salon based on my experience.

  • Anna Clark3 months ago

    Disappointing and dirty: I booked in for a pedicure with my two daughters. When we arrived, they only had availability for one. Then they told us we could not even sit together. I had specifically booked for the three of us to have it done together and requested that we sit together. I had looked around while I was talking to the manager and noted that the pedicure chairs were filthy and broken/cracked. We walked out and certainly will not be back.

  • Monica Wolfson5 months ago

    I go here for all my services, Jack for nails is outstanding and Nubia for waxing! The place is packed because it is great! Your go to for nails!

  • Chantalle Millman5 months ago

    I recently moved to Sag Harbor full-time and finally decided to try Sag Harbor Nails after putting it off because I’m extremely picky about my nails. I walked in expecting “good enough” and instead had one of the best manicure experiences I’ve had in years — thanks to Zoey. I like my nails long, thin, natural-looking, and pale pink, and Zoey immediately understood the look I wanted. She suggested I try Gel-X soft gel extensions instead of my usual dip manicure, and I’m honestly obsessed with the result. The almond shape was a change for me too, but I ended up loving it. She was calm, sweet, patient, detail-oriented, and took her time to make everything look perfect. Finding a new nail person after moving is stressful, but I can officially say I’ve found mine. Already booked myself mentally for a spa pedicure next. Highly recommend Zoey and Sag Harbor Nails!!

  • Suzie Robertsa year ago

    Rating only, no written review.

  • Mason Horna year ago

    Very nice staff! Notice- cash only

  • Celeste Erasmusa year ago

    Wondeful place, got helped immediately, had such nice people taking care of me, no complaints. Thank you guys

  • Melissa Ann Mitchell, PhDa year ago

    Jessie does an amazing job every time! I love my nails and will not go anywhere else. Tell her Melissa sent you!

  • Amarie Jonesa year ago

    I came here on July 6th at 2pm to get sns on my nails and gel pedicure HORRIBLE service no warm welcome even though I set an appointment very young staff no one wanted to work the holiday weekend. Pedicure mediocre at best even though it was $100 massage was sub par my sns look like a kid put pink clay on my nails it’s trash and juvenile at best I ask the nail tech young kid with cartoon shirt to file them more he said why didn’t you say it before sir this is $75 for sns and I asked the file them more he grabbed my hand with an attitude and didn’t do what I asked I work in luxury service this is what the Hamptons have to offer ? Trash never going back if I could give a zero I would

  • Kami Campbella year ago

    They always deliver!! I always end up leaving and loving my nails!

  • Tori Ga year ago

    Just moved to Sag Harbor full time from the city and was nervous about finding a nail place comparable to New York City. Found Sag Harbor nails, and Jack did a phenomenal job. I am so pleased with how my nails turned out. They are better than in the city. He paid very close attention to detail and worked meticulously to make them beautiful. So happy! Thank you Jack. I found my new nail spot.

  • Tiff Li2 years ago

    I will rate this 4.5. Price, staffs were all great. Neat/cleanliness could be better.

  • nb2 years ago

    Rating only, no written review.

  • L DP (LD)2 years ago

    The mani pedi portion was absolutely fine - what was not okay, was the workers from next door smoking right outside the door. It was a beautiful day but because of this they had to shut the door. Some of the technicians weren't too happy about that and honestly I wish they'd left the door open and had the smokers move!! Otherwise its a very nice experience!

  • Sina Hong2 years ago

    Good service,I just spend 1.5 hours to enjoy SPA pedicure,Manicure and Massage❤️❤️❤️. Recommende…..

  • Jialing Wang2 years ago

    Very happy with this experience! The nails are very beautiful! I love it! The service is also great!

  • Sophia Mac2 years ago

    Rating only, no written review.

  • yovani Cardenas2 years ago

    Rating only, no written review.

  • Abigail Hitchcock3 years ago

    Nice people. Great pedicure. Prices are very reasonable for the fashionable Hamptons. 😊 …

  • Hunter Philbrick3 years ago

    The price is reasonable and if you get gel it lasts a long time good staff to

  • Erica B3 years ago

    It’s an average place. What really sucks is the level of entitlement of the customers. They sit gabbing on their phones and the staff do nothing about it. It ruins the experience for those who are considerate of their surroundings. There are other places to go that will enforce the no phones rule.

  • James Rivera3 years ago

    Very friendly staff... Marilyn is great!

  • manuel verzosa4 years ago

    I'm from Tennessee. I am visiting my brother and his family in sag harbor. His wife scheduled massage for her neck and back and asked if I wanted to schedule a massage also. I responded with "HECK YA". My legs and feet hurt due Ms. I was worried a little about the sensitivity of my feet but I took the chance. It was totally worth it. I ordered the foot massage for 1 hr. My massage therapist Tom was amazing. He definitely knew where to hit the right areas and how hard or gentle he had to be. This place has a relaxing atmosphere and well worth a visit. Leo, the receptionist, very friendly and helpful with me getting around. The actual name is called "Happy Feet". Totally recommend this place. Ask for Tom. I'm sure everyone is just as great. Your feet and legs will thank you.

Showing the 25 reviews Google marks as most relevant, of 45. Read all on Google.

Location

Map by Google Maps. Loading it sends your IP address and browser details to Google and lets Google set its own cookies (Google privacy policy).

Open in Google Maps

2 Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, United StatesGet directions

Nail salon in Sag Harbor, NY

Sag Harbor Nail serves Sag Harbor. Its 4 rating comes from 45 customer reviews on Google. Compare it with every spa and salon in Sag Harbor, or browse nail salons across New York.

More spas near Sag Harbor

All in Sag Harbor

Capelli

5(11)

Beauty salon Bridgehampton, NY 4 mi away

JBS Salon

5(6)

Beauty salon Shelter Island, NY 5 mi away

MShair salon

4.6(17)

Beauty salon Southold, NY 8 mi away